Deep Dive

LSAT causal arguments: the four alternative explanations that decide the answer

Key takeaways
• A causal argument jumps from “A and B go together” to “A causes B”. The LSAT tests whether you see the gap.
• Four alternatives break most causal arguments: reverse causation, a third factor, coincidence, and another cause.
• To weaken, raise one alternative. To strengthen, rule one out.
• The assumption underneath is usually “nothing else explains it”.

Causal arguments appear regularly. A study finds that people who do X tend to have Y, and the author concludes that X causes Y. Or something changed, then something else happened, and the author says the first thing is responsible. The conclusion sounds natural, which is exactly why it is such a reliable source of trick answers.

This guide gives you a four-part checklist for causal arguments, shows how it maps onto Strengthen, Weaken, Flaw and Assumption questions, and ends with a worked example. A related trap, answer choices that assert unsupported causation, appears in why wrong answers feel right. Here we take the full version.

How to spot a causal argument

Look for a conclusion that says one thing produces, leads to, is responsible for, or explains another, with evidence that is only about two things appearing together or in sequence.

The evidence says…The conclusion says…
Students who eat breakfast score higherBreakfast improves test scores
Crime fell after the new program beganThe program reduced crime
Cities with more bike lanes have healthier residentsBike lanes make people healthier
Sales rose after the redesignThe redesign caused the increase

In every row the evidence shows that two things are connected. The conclusion adds a claim about direction and cause. That extra claim is the gap.

The four alternative explanations

When you see a causal argument, ask: how else could this pattern appear? There are four standard answers.

AlternativeWhat it saysExample
Reverse causationB actually causes AHealthy people have the energy to exercise, so health causes exercise, not the reverse
A third factorSomething else causes both A and BWealth leads to both private tutoring and high scores
CoincidenceThe link is chance, or the sample is too smallTwo numbers rose together over a short period
Another causeB was caused by something other than ASales rose because a competitor closed, not because of the redesign
The assumption underneath: every causal argument assumes that none of these alternatives is true. If you remember that one sentence, you can answer most causal Assumption, Strengthen and Weaken questions.

How this shows up in each question type

Weaken

The correct answer raises one of the four alternatives or shows the pattern breaking. Common forms: the effect happened without the supposed cause, the supposed cause occurred without the effect, or an independent factor explains the outcome. See how Strengthen and Weaken work for the underlying skill of widening the gap.

Strengthen

The correct answer rules out an alternative or adds support for the link. Common forms: a comparison group with no cause that showed no effect, the effect growing as the cause grows, or a plausible mechanism that connects the two.

Assumption

The correct answer says that an alternative is not happening. Test it with the Denial Test: negate the answer, and if the argument collapses, you have the assumption.

Flaw

The correct answer describes the failure to rule out an alternative, or the move from correlation to causation. Our guide to Flaw questions covers how to name flaws in your own words before you read the choices.

Evaluate the argument

The correct answer is the question whose answer tells you whether an alternative is true, for example whether the effect also appeared where the cause was absent. See Evaluate the Argument questions.

A worked example

The argument
A town added a late-night bus line. In the following year, reported thefts downtown dropped by a fifth. The mayor concludes that the bus line reduced crime.

Which of the following most weakens the argument?
(A) The bus line cost more than projected.
(B) Most riders on the late-night line are students.
(C) During the same year, the downtown police patrol was doubled.
(D) Reported thefts in the suburbs were unchanged over the same year.

Run the four-part checklist. Reverse causation does not apply. A third factor or another cause could. Choice (C) is another cause: doubled patrols could explain the drop with no help from the buses, so it weakens the mayor's conclusion. (A) is about cost and has no bearing on the link. (B) describes who rides, which tells you nothing about thefts. (D) concerns a different area. Note how quickly the checklist narrows the field.

Two traps to avoid

Trap 1: misreading how strong the causal claim is. Read the conclusion's wording. “The program reduced crime” is weaker than “the program is the reason crime fell,” and the strength of the claim changes what counts as a damaging objection. Small wording differences matter, as with quantifier words.

Trap 2: over-weakening. A correct Weaken answer does not need to prove the conclusion false. It only needs to make it less likely. An answer that says the effect also occurred somewhere without the cause is enough.

A drill that builds the reflex

Take ten arguments from recent practice sets. For each one, write the cause and the effect, then list which of the four alternatives is most plausible. After a week, the checklist runs automatically when you meet an argument that sounds like a cause-and-effect story. Keep a note of the ones you miss in your wrong-answer journal so patterns show up.

The short version: a causal conclusion needs the author to have ruled out four alternatives. The test-writer's answer choices are almost always one of those four, either raising it or closing it off.

Related reading

Strengthen and Weaken questions: the two sides of the same coin
The shared skill behind Strengthen and Weaken.
LSAT Flaw questions: the six named errors worth memorizing
Naming the flaws that the LSAT keeps recycling.
The Denial Test: the one LSAT trick that solves half of Assumption questions
A one-step test for finding the assumption.
LSAT Evaluate the Argument questions: finding the one fact that decides the argument
When the answer is a question, not a claim.
See how you handle argument questions.
A free LSAT diagnostic shows which Logical Reasoning question types cost you points.