Deep Dive

LSAT arguments from analogy and authority: what each one quietly assumes

Key takeaways
• Analogy arguments say “it worked there, so it will work here”. They assume the two cases are alike in the way that matters.
• Authority arguments say “an expert says so, so it is true”. They assume the source is qualified, unbiased, and speaking within their field.
• Weaken by showing a relevant difference or a source problem. Strengthen by confirming the similarity or the source's reliability.
• Attacking the source instead of the claim is the mirror-image flaw.

Two argument types rely on borrowed credibility. The first borrows it from a similar case (analogy). The second borrows it from a person or institution (authority). Neither is automatically bad reasoning. In real life we use both constantly. The LSAT cares about what each one assumes, because those hidden assumptions are where Strengthen, Weaken, Flaw and Assumption questions live.

This guide covers both. It also covers a related move, in which an argument is rejected because of who made it. For a wider look at how arguments proceed, see Method of Reasoning questions.

Arguments from analogy

An analogy argument has a simple shape: Case A has property P. Case B is similar to Case A. So Case B has property P.

Example
A city adopted congestion pricing, and traffic fell sharply. A second city, similar to the first, should expect the same result if it adopts it.

The hidden assumption

The argument assumes that the two cases are alike in every relevant respect, meaning the respects that produced the result. The word “relevant” matters. Cities can differ in countless ways, and most differences do not matter. The question is whether they differ in a way that affects the outcome.

Question typeWhat the correct answer does
WeakenShows a relevant difference. Example: the second city has almost no public transit, so drivers have no alternative
StrengthenAdds a relevant similarity or confirms the mechanism. Example: both cities have comparable transit and commuting patterns
AssumptionStates that the two cases are alike in the relevant way
FlawSays the argument overlooks differences between the cases

Arguments from authority

An authority argument says that a claim is true because someone credible said it. The shape: Source S says X. So X is true.

What a good authority argument needs

The argument quietly assumes four things. Each one is a place a test question can attack:

AssumptionHow it gets attacked
The source is qualified in the relevant fieldA physicist is cited on a question about nutrition
The source is not biasedThe expert is paid by a party that benefits from the claim
The source is stating a considered viewThe comment was an offhand remark
Other qualified sources agreeMost experts in the field disagree
Notice the word “relevant”: an expert is only an authority on what they actually know. “A famous scientist said it” is weak support for a claim outside that scientist's field.

Strengthening an authority argument

The correct answer typically adds that the source is well placed to know, has no stake in the outcome, or is backed by other independent sources. Restating the claim adds no support, so such answers are usually wrong.

The mirror image: attacking the source

A related flaw rejects a claim because of who said it, not because of the reasoning. “Her proposal can't be right, because she has never run a business” is an example. The source may lack some credential, but the argument may still be sound. This is the opposite error from accepting a claim only because a credible person said it. Both are about confusing the quality of the source with the quality of the reasoning. See the recurring cast of LSAT flaws for how this fits with others.

Spotting both quickly

Clue wordsArgument type
“just as…”, “similarly…”, “like the case of…”, “comparable to…”Analogy
“according to…”, “experts say…”, “a study by Dr. X shows…”Authority
“she can't be right, because…”, “he has never run one, so…”Attack on the source

A worked example

Argument
A well-known nutrition researcher states that a certain supplement improves memory. So the supplement must improve memory.

Which of the following, if true, most weakens the argument?
(A) The researcher has published many papers.
(B) The supplement manufacturer funds the researcher's lab.
(C) Many people take the supplement.
(D) The supplement is inexpensive.

The argument is an appeal to authority. Check the four assumptions. Choice (B) attacks the second: the source has a financial stake in the claim, which raises doubt about how reliable the statement is. (A) actually supports the researcher's standing. (C) and (D) say nothing about the researcher's reliability.

Where these show up beyond Logical Reasoning

Both patterns appear in Reading Comprehension passages as well. An author may rest a point on a comparison to another field, or cite a scholar's opinion that the passage merely reports. In those cases the question is usually whether the author endorses the comparison or the source. Our guides on author attitude and detail and inference questions show how to keep reported views separate from the author's own.

Practice routine

When you review a practice set, tag each argument you meet: cause, analogy, authority, statistic, or something else. After a week, count how many belong to each group. You will probably find that a few argument types account for most of your errors, which tells you where to practice next. Record them in your wrong-answer journal for easy tracking.

The short version: analogies assume relevant similarity, authority arguments assume a qualified, unbiased source, and attacks on a source ignore the reasoning. Ask what is being assumed, and the right answer usually states it or attacks it.

Related reading

LSAT Method of Reasoning questions: describing structure, not judging it
How to describe what an argument is doing.
Strengthen and Weaken questions: the two sides of the same coin
The shared skill behind Strengthen and Weaken.
LSAT causal arguments: the four alternative explanations that decide the answer
The other argument type that tests hidden assumptions.
LSAT Flaw questions: the six named errors worth memorizing
The flaws the LSAT keeps coming back to.
Find which argument types cost you points.
A free LSAT diagnostic shows which Logical Reasoning question types you miss most.